AI-related case
Swinney v. JHOC, Inc.
False Quotes: Case Law | Counsel attributed the quoted language "whether a worker is a 'borrowed servant' is generally a question of fact to be decided by the jury" to Gorton v. Rance; the court found no such quotation or discussion in the opinion. || False Quotes: Case Law | Counsel claimed Starcher v. Byrne held borrowed-servant disputes are factual issues for the jury and cannot be decided on summary judgment; the court found Starcher does not contain that holding or the quoted language. || Misrepresented: Case Law | Counsel miscited James v. Dedeaux as 242 So. 3d 905 and represented a rule (that facts must be undisputed) that the court says is not the majority holding; the correct citation is 217 So. 3d 785 and the brief appears to rely on a dissent. || Misrepresented: Case Law | Counsel asserted Dawson v. Burgs established specific "elements" (e.g., 'first and most critical element is the existence of a contract of hire') and limits on implied contracts that the court found are not present in Dawson. || Misrepresented: Case Law | Counsel attributed language about 'vicarious liability' and other holdings to Northern Electric Co. v. Phillips that the court could not find in tha…
Judges: Tomika H. Irving