763 current official EOIR judges · Analytics

Immigration judge statistics, made easier to understand.

Look up an immigration judge or court, compare case denial and approval rates, explore rulings by nationality, and review changes over time using official EOIR data.

Rulings by nationality

Compare EOIR-recorded outcomes by judge, nationality, and decision year.

Descriptive historical data—not a prediction or legal advice.

MEXICO · 2026 · 390 published judge/court cells. Showing 50. Rates appear when at least 35 grant-or-denial decisions are available.

Judge ↕	Court ↕	All outcomes ↕	Merits decisions ↕	Grant rate ↕	Denial rate ↕
Xiomara Davis-GumbsEOIR judge code XDD	Dallas Immigration Court	1,423	1,368	0.2%3 grants	99.8%1,365 denials
James F. PolivkaEOIR judge code JFP	Dallas Immigration Court	1,095	1,051	0.2%2 grants	99.8%1,049 denials
Deitrich SimsEOIR judge code DHS	Dallas Immigration Court	1,083	1,016	0.4%4 grants	99.6%1,012 denials
Jennifer WinfieldEOIR judge code JNW	Dallas Immigration Court	1,045	945	0.6%6 grants	99.4%939 denials
James NugentEOIR judge code JN	Dallas Immigration Court	952	918	0.0%0 grants	100.0%918 denials
Elizabeth CottorEOIR judge code EAC	Phoenix Immigration Court	908	737	1.9%14 grants	98.1%723 denials
Jacob J. StenderEOIR judge code JJS	Concord Immigration Court	906	820	0.1%1 grants	99.9%819 denials
Hugo MartinezEOIR judge code HRG	Dallas Immigration Court	902	747	0.0%0 grants	100.0%747 denials
Christopher ThielemannEOIR judge code CTN	Dallas Immigration Court	889	776	0.6%5 grants	99.4%771 denials
Scott CrissEOIR judge code SC2	Charlotte Immigration Court	832	804	0.4%3 grants	99.6%801 denials
Amy LeeEOIR judge code ATL	Charlotte Immigration Court	811	767	0.3%2 grants	99.7%765 denials
John A. PooreEOIR judge code AJP	Dallas Immigration Court	799	785	0.0%0 grants	100.0%785 denials
John CortesEOIR judge code JOC	Phoenix Immigration Court	785	693	0.9%6 grants	99.1%687 denials
Ozmun, Richard R.EOIR judge code RRO	Dallas Immigration Court	774	728	0.1%1 grants	99.9%727 denials
Paul N. JonesEOIR judge code PAJ	Dallas Immigration Court	740	695	0.0%0 grants	100.0%695 denials
Nicholas B. LucicEOIR judge code NIL	El Paso SPC Immigration Court	733	451	0.0%0 grants	100.0%451 denials
Rifian NewazEOIR judge code RSN	San Antonio Immigration Court	709	675	0.4%3 grants	99.6%672 denials
Tyler WoodEOIR judge code TRW	Aurora Immigration Court	707	291	1.4%4 grants	98.6%287 denials
Attila BogdanEOIR judge code ATB	Dallas Immigration Court	694	657	0.2%1 grants	99.8%656 denials
Bianca BrownEOIR judge code BHB	Stewart Immigration Court	694	266	0.8%2 grants	99.2%264 denials
Peter A. KimEOIR judge code PAK	Chicago Immigration Court	694	659	0.0%0 grants	100.0%659 denials
Munish ShardaEOIR judge code MS1	Phoenix Immigration Court	682	545	2.8%15 grants	97.2%530 denials
Marc StahlEOIR judge code MCS	Chicago Immigration Court	659	640	1.6%10 grants	98.4%630 denials
Melissa KarlenEOIR judge code MBK	Phoenix Immigration Court	646	618	3.1%19 grants	96.9%599 denials
Christopher PinedaEOIR judge code CRP	Harlingen Immigration Court	640	519	0.2%1 grants	99.8%518 denials
Paul HabichEOIR judge code PMH	Phoenix Immigration Court	634	557	1.4%8 grants	98.6%549 denials
Brett ParchertEOIR judge code BP1	Seattle Immigration Court	616	514	1.2%6 grants	98.8%508 denials
Delia I GonzalezEOIR judge code DIG	Harlingen Immigration Court	616	460	2.8%13 grants	97.2%447 denials
Brandon HartEOIR judge code BLH	Dallas Immigration Court	600	549	0.2%1 grants	99.8%548 denials
Ryan FisherEOIR judge code RNF	Atlanta - W. Peachtree Street Immigration Court	595	548	0.4%2 grants	99.6%546 denials
Winfield MurrayEOIR judge code WWM	Atlanta - W. Peachtree Street Immigration Court	594	540	0.0%0 grants	100.0%540 denials
Daniel P. KinnicuttEOIR judge code DKT	Conroe Immigration Court	589	2	—Fewer than 35 merits decisions	—Fewer than 35 merits decisions
Michael KlosowskyEOIR judge code MLK	Chicago Immigration Court	583	550	0.7%4 grants	99.3%546 denials
Jennifer GazEOIR judge code JIG	Phoenix Immigration Court	572	498	4.6%23 grants	95.4%475 denials
Ana MenciniEOIR judge code AAM	Chicago Immigration Court	561	478	4.4%21 grants	95.6%457 denials
Alexandra LarsenEOIR judge code ARL	Omaha Immigration Court	558	500	0.4%2 grants	99.6%498 denials
Matthew C. BeeseEOIR judge code MCB	Chicago Immigration Court	557	492	0.2%1 grants	99.8%491 denials
Shadee M. StarEOIR judge code SMS	Concord Immigration Court	550	513	0.8%4 grants	99.2%509 denials
Cynthia LaFuenteEOIR judge code CLG	San Antonio Immigration Court	549	490	0.8%4 grants	99.2%486 denials
Charles McCulloughEOIR judge code CMM	San Antonio Immigration Court	545	495	1.8%9 grants	98.2%486 denials
Amy F. HaerEOIR judge code AFH	Atlanta - W. Peachtree Street Immigration Court	543	490	0.0%0 grants	100.0%490 denials
Valerie BurchEOIR judge code VAB	Indianapolis Immigration Court	543	476	0.2%1 grants	99.8%475 denials
Michelle VenciEOIR judge code MEV	Chicago Immigration Court	541	466	0.4%2 grants	99.6%464 denials
Joshua LuskinEOIR judge code JAL	Chicago Immigration Court	539	496	2.6%13 grants	97.4%483 denials
Scott ThomsenEOIR judge code STT	Indianapolis Immigration Court	536	478	0.4%2 grants	99.6%476 denials
Shane JohnsonEOIR judge code SEJ	Seattle Immigration Court	533	484	1.9%9 grants	98.1%475 denials
Marlem NavaEOIR judge code MWN	Concord Immigration Court	532	492	0.0%0 grants	100.0%492 denials
Christopher GreerEOIR judge code CMG	Salt Lake City Immigration Court	527	469	3.4%16 grants	96.6%453 denials
Caley, StevenEOIR judge code SDC	Portland Immigration Court	525	408	2.5%10 grants	97.5%398 denials
Emmanuel GarciaEOIR judge code ELG	Laredo Immigration Court	524	462	0.0%0 grants	100.0%462 denials

Methodology