United States Judicial Registry
KnowJudges.com
Menu

763 current official EOIR judges · Analytics

Immigration judge statistics, made easier to understand.

Look up an immigration judge or court, compare case denial and approval rates, explore rulings by nationality, and review changes over time using official EOIR data.

Judge denial rate vs court benchmark

Judge-specific asylum outcomes compared with the EOIR base-city context in the same official dataset.

EOIR judge denial rates compared with court benchmarksEach point is a current judge with a direct EOIR asylum decision rate and an EOIR court comparator. The shaded band marks ten percentage points above or below the court benchmark.Abby Meyer: 89.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,888Abdias Tida: 86.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=235Abraham Burgess: 75.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,164Adam Jovanovic: 94.4% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=628Adam Panopoulos: 79.7% judge denial · 59.1% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=516Adam Perl: 83.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,625Adam R. Morris: 95.2% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=83Adam Rodriguez: 100.0% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=62Adrien Lee-Lo: 71.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=62Aggie Norregard: 91.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,242Akash B. Vyas: 85.2% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=54Alec Niziolek: 70.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=825Alex G. Mason: 100.0% judge denial · 64.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=170Alex Perez: 91.6% judge denial · 81.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=818Alexander Lee: 91.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=889Alexandra Larsen: 90.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,361Alice Hartye: 63.2% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,165Alicia Brooks: 77.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=938Alisha Campos: 76.9% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=756Alison Igoe: 61.6% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=800Alison Kane: 58.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,288Allan John-Baptiste: 89.6% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=791Alysha Welsh: 70.8% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=585Amanda Jeannopoulos: 50.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,212Amelia Anderson: 64.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=822Amy F. Haer: 84.6% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=624Amy Lee: 71.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,040Amy Sigmon Walker: 100.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=39Ana L. Quiros: 74.2% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=561Ana Mencini: 70.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=823André Carman: 85.2% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=81Andrea Cole: 93.6% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=267Andrea Hong: 63.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,088Andrea Siebert: 56.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=773Andrew F. Scafidi: 100.0% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=69Andrew Fishkin: 71.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,227Andrew Galvao: 100.0% judge denial · 20.3% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=55Andrew Hewitt: 95.5% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=335Andrew J. Slitt: 89.1% judge denial · 57.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=46Andrew M. Calvelli: 52.3% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,144Andrew X. Stawar: 97.1% judge denial · 81.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=787Angela Munson: 74.5% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=396Anibal Martinez: 48.9% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,147Anita McFadden: 80.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=753Anita Simons: 49.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,743Ann M. McDermott: 55.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,279Anna Adams: 77.2% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=705Anna C. Little: 41.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,647Anna Diao: 77.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=540Anne Kristina Perry: 66.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=830Anthony A. Picione: 100.0% judge denial · 52.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=96Anthony J. Hurst: 99.6% judge denial · 59.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=266Anthony Maingot: 74.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,259Antonio Capistrano: 67.2% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=930Anupriya Krishna: 96.9% judge denial · 81.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=128Anwer Khan: 90.5% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,478Arkesia Jenkins-Dargan: 94.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=687Arlene E. Dorfman: 44.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,691Artie Pobjecky: 96.1% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=685Arya Ranasinghe: 75.1% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=727Attila Bogdan: 97.4% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=151Audra Behne: 54.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,202Audrey Carr: 74.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,184Aviva Poczter: 35.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=4,635Ayodele A. Gansallo: 52.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=472Bao Nguyen: 81.8% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,168Barbara A. Nelson: 46.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=10,809Bayleigh J. Pettigrew: 91.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=45Benjamin D. Rosen: 81.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=747Benjamin S. Kuipers: 98.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=70Benjamin Sky Brown: 98.3% judge denial · 93.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=60Bianca Brown: 87.7% judge denial · 81.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=488Bill Radin: 100.0% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=133Billy Sapp: 86.3% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=611Blake Doughty: 88.9% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,306Bobbie C. Masters: 86.8% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=646Bradley R. Burke: 100.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=62Brandi M. Lohr: 77.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=383Brandon Alexander “Alex” Kennedy: 100.0% judge denial · 59.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=59Brandon Hart: 84.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,182Brandon Josephsen: 77.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=549Brendan Curran: 71.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=684Brent Jostad: 88.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=383Brett Parchert: 56.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=5,931Brian Burke: 57.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,164Brian Counihan: 88.9% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=126Brian Palmer: 75.7% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,718Brian Sardelli: 88.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,456Brittany A. Rodriquez: 97.6% judge denial · 52.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=41Brock Taylor: 53.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,277Bruce Imbacuan: 90.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=812Bruce Taylor: 41.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,706Bryan DePowell: 93.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=321C. Morgan Kim: 96.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=93Carey Holliday: 75.5% judge denial · 99.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,757Carlos Juelle: 61.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,533Carol A. Crawford: 51.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,112Carol Moore: 76.6% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,031Carolyn L. Krasinski: 65.9% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=904Carrie Johnson-Papillo: 71.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,585Cassie Thogersen: 95.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=626Catherine Halliday-Roberts: 65.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=593Cathy Sagesse: 52.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,913Chad Dotson: 89.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=220Charles Floyd: 67.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=480Charles M. Ouslander: 81.3% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=560Charles McCullough: 58.4% judge denial · 61.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,358Charles Purnell: 97.7% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=522Charles R. Conroy: 69.5% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,262Charlotte Marquez: 87.7% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,737Chevone Sanon: 68.7% judge denial · 57.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=348Chris Brisack: 61.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,987Chris Staszak: 100.0% judge denial · 100.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=40Christian Michael Pressman: 60.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=450Christina Martyak: 94.9% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=447Christine Lluis Reis: 78.7% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,148Christine Olson: 84.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=403Christopher Cooper: 98.2% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=227Christopher Cusmano: 89.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=104Christopher Greer: 55.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,972Christopher Phan: 86.6% judge denial · 61.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=911Christopher Pineda: 82.3% judge denial · 61.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=158Christopher Raish Ford: 99.2% judge denial · 61.6% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=129Christopher Schumann: 93.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=823Christopher Stephens: 83.3% judge denial · 64.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=84Christopher Thielemann: 84.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=818Clayton M. Lawrence: 98.1% judge denial · 66.1% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=52Colin Johnson: 76.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=622Courtney Stevens: 96.0% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=223Craig A. Newell Jr.: 86.7% judge denial · 57.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=45Craig DeFoe: 71.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,636Curtis Pierce: 55.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,487Curtis White: 72.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=389Cynthia Goodman: 88.9% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=396Cynthia LaFuente: 61.3% judge denial · 64.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=812Cynthia Torg: 68.8% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,176D'Anna H. Freeman: 72.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,228Dalin Holyoak: 57.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,133Damona Taef Hakiman: 81.0% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=79Dania Nassar: 65.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,645Daniel A. Morris: 59.4% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,354Daniel Conklin: 88.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=966Daniel Dowell: 51.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=9,276Daniel J. Daugherty: 54.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=928Daniel Malvin: 30.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,375Daniel P. Kinnicutt: 89.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=175Daniel Santander: 34.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,397Danielle Garten: 99.5% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=432Danny Razo: 76.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=414Dara F. Reid: 83.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,187Darian R. Etienne: 100.0% judge denial · 64.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=76Darin W. Flagg: 91.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=71David Anderson: 43.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=4,543David Evans: 73.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,599David G. Beyleryan: 100.0% judge denial · 64.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=65David Gardey: 86.6% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=710David J. Green: 95.6% judge denial · 99.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=91David Jones: 58.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,260David M. Paxton: 90.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=475David Russo: 67.5% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=804David Whipple: 59.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=486David White: 95.4% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=548Dawn Kulick: 51.4% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=537Dean Tuckman: 79.8% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=322Deborah D. Dictson: 100.0% judge denial · 59.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=111Deborah E. Klahr: 59.7% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,181Deepali Nadkarni: 50.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,116Deitrich Sims: 59.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=3,342DeLana Jones: 96.2% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=678Delia I Gonzalez: 74.6% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=567Denise Kallas: 98.0% judge denial · 69.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=99Denise M. Bowen: 95.9% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=74Denise Marks Lane: 49.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=7,044Dennis Ryan: 91.5% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=697Diana L. Callaghan: 73.0% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=318Diane L. Dodd: 75.2% judge denial · 61.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=499Dimple Gupta: 84.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=311Dinesh Verma: 53.6% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,829Donald Eller: 87.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,021Donald Pashayan: 84.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=792Dorothy Harbeck: 41.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,789Elisa M. Sukkar: 39.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=4,407Elizabeth Cottor: 76.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,306Elizabeth Kessler: 53.1% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=3,129Elizabeth Lang: 61.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,336Elizabeth Martinez: 83.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=320Ellaine Loreto Goss: 100.0% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=52Elvin Talavera-Peraza: 89.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=672Emily Farrar-Crockett: 73.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,309Emmanuel Garcia: 97.9% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=193Eric Marsteller: 72.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,696Eric Schultz: 92.6% judge denial · 100.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=176Eric Stransky: 98.7% judge denial · 52.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=153Eric Tijerina: 71.2% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=927Eric Wang: 100.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=85Eugene Robinson: 57.6% judge denial · 34.1% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=766F. James Loprest Jr.: 26.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=3,670Fayaz Habib: 82.4% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=472Forrest Hoover: 73.2% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,421Francis Mwangi: 78.6% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=556Francisco Mendez: 57.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,440Francisco R. Prieto: 65.3% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,237Frank Pimentel: 84.2% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=822Frank Seminerio: 71.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=3,035Gary Endelman: 84.6% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=4,425Gary L. Bergosh: 88.9% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=126Geoffrey Hoffman: 84.9% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=807George Ward: 80.7% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=971Georgina Picos: 86.6% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,932Ghunise L. Coaxum: 94.4% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=786Gilda Terrazas: 77.4% judge denial · 52.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=864Gioia Maiellano: 72.0% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=947Gordan S. Vincent: 93.8% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=305Gregory Simmons: 73.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,212Gurney F. Pearsall III: 92.2% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=103Guy Grande: 67.2% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=726Harold “Hal” Moroz: 96.4% judge denial · 93.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=56Hayden Windrow: 69.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,150Heather Libeu: 88.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=702Holly D'Andrea: 76.0% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=350Howard Hom: 71.0% judge denial · 43.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,665Hugo Martinez: 89.5% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,025Hye Chon: 76.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,996Ian Simons: 64.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,438Illya-Karina Bonet: 79.2% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=838Iman Ghasri: 87.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,036Irene C. Feldman: 62.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=611Irene Recio: 73.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=712Irma Diaz: 88.1% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,056Irma Newburn: 90.7% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=589Ivan Gardzelewski: 74.6% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,233J. Thomas Bartleson: 43.2% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=932Jacinto Palomino: 65.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,160Jacob Bashore: 83.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=727Jacob J. Stender: 54.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=619Jacob T. Addicott: 98.3% judge denial · 59.1% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=59Jacob Weintraub: 91.1% judge denial · 66.1% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=45Jacquelyn Jo. Joyce: 97.3% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=402Jaime Jasso: 71.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=999Jaime Poarch: 100.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=55James A. Klinedinst: 95.3% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=170James Crofts: 97.3% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=370James Dehn: 73.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=730James F. Polivka: 91.9% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=708James Graulich: 92.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=496James K. Glober: 85.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=113James M. McCarthy: 59.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,181James M. Rice: 100.0% judge denial · 69.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=147James Miller Jr.: 86.7% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=885James Nugent: 56.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=971James R. McKee: 88.3% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,250James W. Kitchen: 100.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=115Jane Miller: 99.5% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=772Jankana Desai: 45.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,123Jared L. Grimmer: 100.0% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=76Jason Braun: 56.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=316Jason Hermus: 99.5% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=192Jason L. Stern: 95.9% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=707Jason Pope: 75.8% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,784Jason R. Waterloo: 64.5% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=777Jason Thomas: 96.2% judge denial · 99.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=79Javier Balasquide: 45.7% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=4,974Jayme Salinardi: 81.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,452Jean M. Kilker: 86.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=86Jeannette Park: 40.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,008Jeffrey Frederick: 61.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=585Jeffrey Munoz: 47.5% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=482Jeffrey Sprague: 90.1% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=253Jeffry S. Brady: 96.4% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=83Jennifer Chung: 69.5% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,850Jennifer Gaz: 72.9% judge denial · 81.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,619Jennifer May: 92.3% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=950Jennifer Page-Lozano: 80.0% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,733Jennifer Piateski: 79.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=523Jennifer R. Bell: 77.5% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=311Jennifer Riedthaler-Williams: 71.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=710Jennifer S. Wells: 100.0% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=101Jennifer Winfield: 90.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=912Jeremy Santoro: 82.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=527Jerome M. Day: 100.0% judge denial · 76.1% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=42Jerrica Harness: 92.2% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=129Jessica Miles: 82.8% judge denial · 53.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=203Jesus J. Ybarra: 98.5% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=67Jill K. Krishnan: 91.3% judge denial · 69.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=46Johanna Gaymer: 91.9% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=74John A. Poore: 96.3% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=161John C. Barnes: 80.4% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=915John Carle: 60.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,330John Cortes: 82.9% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,108John DeCure: 76.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,284John E. Moriarty: 97.8% judge denial · 59.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=46John Furlong Jr.: 66.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,092John J. Siemietkowski: 66.2% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,421John McPhail: 96.2% judge denial · 61.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=494John Odell: 64.8% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,433John P. Burns: 97.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,734John P. Fucetola: 94.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=149John Rubenstein: 71.9% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,054Jon P. Calandruccio: 92.3% judge denial · 84.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=52Jonathan Andresen: 100.0% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=62Jonathan Daniel Pelletier: 55.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,579Jonathan Huang: 89.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,025Jonathan M. Brent: 75.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=68Jonathan Owens: 77.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=549Jonathan Reingold: 64.2% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,034Jonathan W. Hitesman: 61.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=291Jorene Soto: 96.6% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=58Jorge Pereira: 90.0% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=402Jose Penalosa: 73.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,054Jose Rivera-Ortiz: 82.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,129Joseph Kassell: 91.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=642Joseph LaRocca: 67.7% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,746Joseph Leonard: 75.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=554Joseph Q. Andelin: 91.7% judge denial · 76.3% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=72Joseph Scott: 60.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,161Joseph Weiner: 69.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=712Joshua D. Rosen: 88.2% judge denial · 59.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=76Joshua Luskin: 55.8% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=755Joshua Osborn: 90.3% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=934Joy Lampley-Fortson: 100.0% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=81Joyce Bakke Varzandeh: 23.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=3,352Joyce Noche: 74.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,251Juan Román: 99.5% judge denial · 32.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=185Judith Bonilla: 65.2% judge denial · 61.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=376Julia Diaz-Rex: 81.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=688Julia Egy: 75.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=820Julian Castaneda: 84.6% judge denial · 69.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=642Julie Adams: 95.3% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=170Julie Nelson: 80.7% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,220June Lee: 76.8% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=871Justin Adams: 87.2% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,272Justin Dinsdale: 98.1% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=700Kalenna Lee: 72.9% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=743Kalin Ivany: 88.9% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=876Kamra Sellers Craig: 98.3% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=120Kandra Robbins: 87.2% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=563Karen Nazaire: 88.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=816Karen Y. Hope: 85.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=631Katherine Hansen: 43.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=990Kathleen E. Byrne: 86.4% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=88Kathryn DeAngelis: 42.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,594Katie Mullins: 96.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=258Keira A. Poellet: 86.5% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=111Keith E. Lipiec: 96.8% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=95Kelley Sydnor: 91.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=764Kelly Johnson: 93.9% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=657Kelly Lake: 62.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=851Kenneth Flesch: 95.1% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=81Kenneth Shahan: 88.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=554Kenneth Sogabe: 83.0% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,120Kenya Wells: 97.5% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=956Kevin Brown: 97.0% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,078Kevin Gross: 95.4% judge denial · 61.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=194Kevin N. Buras: 95.8% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=72Kevin Riley: 77.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,521Kevin Stanley: 81.8% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=760Kevin Terrill: 96.6% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=324Khalilah M. Taylor: 59.7% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=159Kiera Parikh: 98.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=264Kieran M. Lalor: 94.3% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=193Kimberly B. Jeter: 97.1% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=68Kristie Anne Padron: 61.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=654Kristin Piepmeier: 91.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,523Kristopher McDonald: 65.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,073Kuyomars Golparvar: 83.2% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,720Kyle Mitchell: 100.0% judge denial · 61.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=122Kyle Myers: 81.6% judge denial · 64.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=98Kyung Auh: 64.6% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=387Lakshmi Herman: 74.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=557Laura Figueroa: 47.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,200Laura Wyrosdick: 52.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=792Lauren F. Farber: 50.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,114Lauren M. Black: 100.0% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=91Laurie Samuels: 100.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=65Leah A. O'Brien: 84.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=96Leila A. McNeill Mullican: 70.9% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,144Lena Golovnin: 43.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,724Lenka J. Koss: 87.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=123Leon Francis: 82.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,921Lettricea Jefferson-Webb: 51.5% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=820Lian Yeh: 100.0% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=50Lily Hsu: 80.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,116Linda Hristova: 88.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=269Lindsay W. Pepi: 80.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=373Lindsy R. Roberts: 47.2% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=975Lisa de Cardona: 73.6% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,641Lisa W. Ling: 59.9% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=3,594Lolita Lukose: 54.4% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,044Lorely Fernandez: 81.9% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,150Lorianne M. Campanella: 63.8% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,591Lourdes Martinez-Esquivel: 66.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,471Lourdes Rodriguez de Jongh: 50.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,407Lucas I. Abbott: 100.0% judge denial · 52.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=49Luciana Dubuc: 97.4% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=76Lucky Narain: 100.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=35Lucy Baez: 78.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=950Luisa Santiago: 79.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=397Luther Snavely: 92.5% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,271Lydia Tamez: 91.5% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,009Lynn Wang: 93.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=827Madeline Garcia: 76.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,768Maithe Gonzalez: 87.1% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=225Marc Stahl: 52.3% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,493Margaret Kolbe: 34.0% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,883Margaret R. MacGregor: 86.8% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=319Maria Akalski: 95.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,488Maria Jaimes-Salgado: 89.2% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=618Maria T. Ubarri: 54.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=578Mario Sturla: 63.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,351Marion S. Mishkin: 95.7% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=47Maritza Ramos: 90.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=972Mark Jebson: 84.8% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,075Mark Sameit: 69.1% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=470Marla Gillman: 96.3% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=54Marlem Nava: 66.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=656Marni Guerrero: 83.8% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,307Marsha Nettles: 64.3% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,696Martin R. Celis: 100.0% judge denial · 64.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=60Martinque Parker: 96.5% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=548Marvin E. Richards: 100.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=35Mary C. Baumgarten: 89.2% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,171Mary Futcher: 86.1% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=230Mary Lee: 68.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,924Matthew A. Kozyra: 88.7% judge denial · 51.6% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=53Matthew A. McLeod: 93.2% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=190Matthew Andrasko: 97.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=132Matthew C. Beese: 94.6% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=224Matthew C. Wallace: 75.7% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=37Matthew Chan: 81.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=793Matthew E. Sweet: 82.1% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=84Matthew Gordon: 66.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=531Matthew Morrissey: 92.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,490Matthew W. Kaufman: 69.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,200Megan H. Eyes: 89.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=112Melissa Fox: 86.7% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=218Melissa Joy Garcia: 66.9% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=154Melissa Karlen: 78.6% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=658Melissa L. Isaak: 98.0% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=49Meredith Duff: 100.0% judge denial · 53.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=35Meredith Tyrakoski: 68.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,092Michael G. McFarland: 40.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,916Michael Hussey: 85.7% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=42Michael Klosowsky: 69.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,262Michael Lewis: 68.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=723Michael Matthew Osterberg: 89.6% judge denial · 53.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=48Michael Neal: 90.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=767Michael Paul Taylor: 94.6% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=149Michael Pleters: 81.5% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=546Michael Schnitzer: 91.5% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=351Michael Tisocco: 86.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,624Michael Tripi: 81.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=899Michael W. Lloyd: 76.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,109Michael Walleisa: 85.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,269Michelle Araneta: 81.4% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=661Michelle Kahan: 64.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,276Michelle Lakomy: 60.8% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=502Michelle Slayton: 40.9% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=748Michelle Venci: 73.6% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=647Miguel Cordero-Gonzalez: 93.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=453Monica Guidry: 90.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=958Monica Neumann: 89.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=561Monte Horton: 75.7% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=973Monte Miller: 90.6% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,771Munish Sharda: 83.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,122Nancy Miller: 68.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,043Natalie Huddleston: 71.9% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=687Natalie Smith: 80.2% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=455Nathan Herbert: 79.5% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=395Nathan M. Hansen: 97.7% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=266Nathaniel B. Walker: 79.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=928Nelson Vargas-Padilla: 65.2% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,988Nicholas B. Lucic: 98.7% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=76Nicholas Martz: 84.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,311Nicholle Hempel: 93.6% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=639Nicolas Orechwa: 90.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=375Nicole I. Wells: 90.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=143Nicole Lane: 91.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,581Nimmo Bhagat: 85.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=4,156Nina M. Carbone: 62.6% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,195Njeri Maldonado: 89.4% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,156Norman J. Schroth: 94.4% judge denial · 69.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=90Olga Attia: 79.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=681Omar J. Famada: 97.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=144Omar Z. Karram: 93.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=66Oshea Spencer: 84.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,338Pallavi Shirole: 72.6% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,146Patricia Walter: 100.0% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=49Patrick A. Espana: 81.6% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=49Patrick Barrett: 94.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=177Patrick Burke: 84.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=497Patrick E. Moore: 99.2% judge denial · 99.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=260Patrick McKenna: 62.6% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,551Paul Edmond Stephan: 100.0% judge denial · 61.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=60Paul Habich: 71.5% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,524Paul Hable: 93.1% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=522Paul McCloskey: 86.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,216Paul Medved: 82.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,428Paul N. Jones: 98.9% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=88Pedro Espinal: 75.8% judge denial · 61.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=545Peter A. Kim: 53.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=669Philip P. Taylor: 83.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=552Phoebe D. Riner: 100.0% judge denial · 59.1% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=77Rachel Ruane: 42.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,176Ralph Girvin: 93.0% judge denial · 67.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=386Randall Fluke: 81.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=838Raphael Choi: 77.4% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=944Raphael Rojas: 64.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=667Ravit Halperin: 87.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=693Rebecca Niburg: 57.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=956Rene Mateo: 52.8% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,318Revathi Muneer: 96.9% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=128Richard B. Cato: 62.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=760Richard Drucker: 67.9% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,782Richard J. Douglas: 100.0% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=118Richard Jacobs: 87.2% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=779Richard Jamadar: 71.8% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,505Richard S. Holloway: 86.6% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=67Richard Vanveldhuisen: 69.6% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=681Rico Sogocio: 81.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,324Rifian Newaz: 73.6% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,401Robert G. Eastman: 100.0% judge denial · 57.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=47Robert G. Palmer: 98.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=85Robert K. Lundberg: 72.6% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=646Robert L. Gundlach: 55.2% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,100Robert L. Martin: 92.9% judge denial · 64.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=98Robert Lewandowski: 92.9% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=731Robert P. Driscoll: 83.8% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=309Robert Powell: 62.7% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,048Robert R. McKee: 73.7% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=866Roberto Amaya: 88.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=828Robyn Ross: 90.9% judge denial · 67.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=44Rodger Harris: 60.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,685Rodin Rooyani: 26.5% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,925Roel Canales: 91.1% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=361Romaine White: 94.6% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,170Romy Lerner: 84.4% judge denial · 61.6% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=480Ryan Fisher: 92.4% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=939Ryan Thompson: 88.2% judge denial · 57.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=51Sam Brown: 96.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,886Samia Naseem: 53.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,145Samuel G. Williams: 99.6% judge denial · 53.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=251Samuel M. Factor: 45.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,703Sandra Santos-Garcia: 67.2% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,429Sarah Mazzie: 80.2% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,137Sarah Sawwan: 100.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=64Saul Greenstein: 75.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,231Scott Alexander: 56.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=7,082Scott Bratton: 82.8% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,485Scott Criss: 87.1% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,434Scott Laragy: 85.0% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=439Scott Simpson: 58.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=674Scott Thomsen: 51.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,425Scott V. Greenbaum: 98.8% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=168Shadee M. Star: 46.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,356Shana Chen: 89.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,553Shane Johnson: 82.2% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,267ShaSha Xu: 81.8% judge denial · 100.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=461Shawn J. Abraham: 100.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=126Shayne M. Welling: 100.0% judge denial · 64.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=80Shayne R. Burnham: 61.7% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,084Sherease R. Pratt: 65.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=871Sherron Ashworth: 90.4% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=239Shirley Lazare-Raphael: 77.2% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,901Stephanie Arrache: 98.7% judge denial · 62.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=78Stephen Mander: 46.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=6,371Stephen P. Alcorn: 98.4% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=186Stephen Ruhle: 69.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=926Stephen Stewart: 94.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=533Steve Mannion: 92.0% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=830Steven Fuller: 93.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=460Steven Kirchner: 50.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,966Steven Marcus: 80.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=869Steven Meredith: 97.8% judge denial · 67.0% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=89Stuart Alcorn: 72.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=739Stuart Siegel: 89.1% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,215Sujata Rodgers: 100.0% judge denial · 69.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=110Susan Phan: 45.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,370Susanna Martinez: 88.6% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=70Suzette Smikle: 86.3% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=693Taiyyeba S. Skomra: 67.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=755Tamar Wilson: 79.6% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=960Tamara S. Wallen: 76.3% judge denial · 43.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=38Tammy Fitting: 51.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,931Tanawa Lebreton: 58.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=704Tanisha Bowens-McCatty: 57.6% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=884Tara Naselow-Nahas: 71.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=3,501Taylor A. Gillespie: 100.0% judge denial · 42.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=56Teresa L. Riley: 79.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=826Terese Tadros-Ibarra: 70.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=676Terexa Fan: 99.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=101Thanos Kanellakos: 70.3% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=748Theresa Holmes-Simmons: 34.1% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=4,696Theresa M. Scala: 49.5% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,292Thomas Ayze: 88.8% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,585Thomas B. Fighter: 100.0% judge denial · 64.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=36Thomas C. Allmond: 95.1% judge denial · 72.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=81Thomas C. Weisert: 97.6% judge denial · 64.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=84Thomas Crossan: 56.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,646Tiesha Peal: 79.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,112Timothy Everett: 55.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,828Timothy M. Cole: 77.7% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,496Tod M. Thedy: 100.0% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=92Todd A. Masters: 63.1% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,587Traci Winder: 97.8% judge denial · 48.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=45Tyler Wood: 85.3% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=694Ubaid ul-Haq: 73.9% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=176Valerie Burch: 73.6% judge denial · 47.2% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,243Veronica Segovia: 95.4% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=284Veronica Villegas: 23.0% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,511Victoria Levin: 51.6% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=347Virna Wright: 30.9% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=4,498Wade Napier: 79.5% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=673Warren Kaufman: 100.0% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=43Watson P. Berich: 95.2% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=42Wilbur Lee: 88.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,016William H. McDermott: 44.2% judge denial · 46.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=874William Mabry III: 54.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=488William Velez Quinones: 100.0% judge denial · 93.8% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=38Winfield Murray: 70.0% judge denial · 81.4% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=584Xavier Racine: 72.1% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,038Xiomara Davis-Gumbs: 75.3% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,000Yeshaya Poyurs: 100.0% judge denial · 59.1% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=66Yon Alberdi: 73.7% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=2,026Yul-mi Cho: 82.1% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=497Yvan Murad: 47.4% judge denial · 63.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=618Yvonne Gonzalez: 53.3% judge denial · 67.5% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=1,125Zachary McFarland: 91.5% judge denial · 63.7% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=47Zol Rainey: 90.2% judge denial · 81.9% EOIR court benchmark · Decisions=59415%100%100%15%

X = EOIR court-context denial rate · Y = judge-specific EOIR denial rate · Decisions ≥ 35 · 628 judges plotted.

EOIR asylum outcomes by fiscal year

Current official judge cohort · judge-specific qualifying asylum decisions.

FY2026 is partial through the EOIR data build dated September 17, 2026.

EOIR asylum outcome rates by fiscal yearGranted and denied shares of qualifying judge-specific asylum decisions for current official judges from fiscal year 2021 through fiscal year 2026.0%25%50%75%100%FY2021: 34.8% grantedFY2021: 64.8% deniedFY2021FY2022: 37.9% grantedFY2022: 62.0% deniedFY2022FY2023: 41.1% grantedFY2023: 58.8% deniedFY2023FY2024: 31.5% grantedFY2024: 68.5% deniedFY2024FY2025: 14.4% grantedFY2025: 85.6% deniedFY2025FY2026: 5.0% grantedFY2026: 95.0% deniedFY2026PARTIAL
Fiscal yearQualifying decisionsGrantedDeniedOther / procedural
FY202117,1315,960 · 34.8%11,100 · 64.8%71 · 0.4%
FY202242,33316,035 · 37.9%26,235 · 62.0%63 · 0.1%
FY202349,32620,251 · 41.1%29,021 · 58.8%54 · 0.1%
FY202454,95817,314 · 31.5%37,627 · 68.5%17 · 0.0%
FY2025100,94114,524 · 14.4%86,400 · 85.6%17 · 0.0%
FY2026 (partial)104,7435,250 · 5.0%99,479 · 95.0%14 · 0.0%

Official EOIR FOIA application decisions only. Counts use the current 763-judge roster and do not mix sources or denominators.

Methodology